For a patient with an unrepaired hole in the heart, or with long-standing rheumatic mitral stenosis, the level and reversibility of pulmonary pressure is the question on which everything turns. If the lung arteries are still responsive, closing the defect or relieving the valve is worthwhile and pressures usually fall. If they have remodelled permanently, closing the defect removes the escape route and can precipitate right heart failure. Echocardiography estimates the pressure but cannot answer the question properly — that requires right heart catheterisation with testing of how the circulation responds to a vasodilator. Any plan to close a shunt in an adult without that study is incomplete.